Is Your Teen Reluctant to Get Their Driver’s License? Should You Push Them?

I turned 16 in 1988, and like many teens in the 1980s (and many decades prior), getting your driver’s license on the day you turned 16 wasn’t the exception, it was the absolute rule. There was no delaying it for one single day. You were there when the doors of the DMV opened on your birthday, then a few hours later you were cruising to the closest McDonald’s, experiencing that first sweet taste of total independence and pure freedom.

What Happened to Teen Driving Culture?

Teen driving culture has shifted dramatically over the last several years and for a variety of reasons, some duly justified and some just a matter of a teen’s disinterest. The housing bust and following recession brought with it tight purse strings when it came to having to buy a car for a teenager, and increasing car insurance rates added to an already out of reach expense for many. 

teen driving
Some teens are reluctant to learn to drive. (@kayp via Twenty20)

Add to that some technological gains – think smartphones and FaceTime, and teenagers today have no need to hop in their cars to go find friends, parties, or hang out, when they can do all of the above from the comfort of their own bedrooms.

Finally, in many states budgets cuts are forcing the total deletion of high school driver education programs, offering only “online” versions of the class. (Also, how do you learn to drive online?)  But ironically, because so many students would rather replace a driver’s ed elective course with an AP class anyway – because they’re on the fast (and non-driving) track to college, most teens don’t even notice or care. 

Their schedules are too filled up anyways, and who has time to learn to drive when you already have 18 hour days? The bigger question may be, who even needs to learn how to drive when moms and dads are more than willing to taxi our teenagers everywhere anyway?

Teens Are Taking a Longer Time to Learn Life Skills, Like Driving

But there’s also something else going on here, something that educators and adolescent psychologists are noticing and referring to as “a delay in both the responsibilities and pleasures of adulthood, or a slow-life strategy.”  In other words, today’s teens are taking longer to do certain things that we did at more age appropriate times, driving being a big one.

Even with graduated licensing programs commonplace across the country, where nervous new drivers are required to complete a year or more of driving with an adult before getting a license to drive solo, teens are still delaying the whole process.

Parents with reluctant drivers say their teens are expressing they just don’t feel “ready” or “comfortable” driving yet, and they’re also using words like “anxious,” “panicky,” and “scared” when referring to getting behind the wheel.  Obviously, these same worried and concerned parents don’t want to put hesitant teens who lack driving confidence into cars because of the myriad of potential dangers that would bring, so many are content with playing taxi service until their teens are finally 100% ready. 

Unfortunately, this could mean they’re continuing to chauffeur throughout all of high school and even beyond, schlepping kids to school, jobs, sports, even dates, and all at a time when those same teens should be beginning the natural process of doing more independent and freedom centered activities -which by definition includes the very necessary adult skill of driving.

But do we wait patiently (and as long as it takes) until they say they’re ready to drive? Do we gently nudge and encourage them, making them practice driving with us on occasion,  but still allow them to delay getting a license to drive solo,  only doing so on their timeline?

Or do we push them out of the safety driving nest so to speak, in much the same way we did when we removed training wheels from bikes, or took floaties off in swimming pools, or pushed scared and crying kindergarteners into classrooms? We weren’t being callous then, we were encouraging and cheering them on, but in a way yes, we were forcing them to do something they didn’t feel comfortable doing, because sometimes that’s we do as parents, especially when we’re trying to raise capable adults.

Laura Adams is a safety and education analyst for driversed.com, and she has a few suggestions on how to handle reluctant teen drivers, as well as ways parents can safely get them on the road and out of the passenger seat.

She says that today’s teens are lacking many of the incentives we had as teenagers to drive, including the need to socialize in person with their peers and getting there by car,  because social media is now the conduit for hanging out. Ride sharing services like Uber and Lyft are also growing popular with teens, who can easily group up and share the costs of rides to movies, etc.

She also believes that teens are inundated with only the “dangers” of driving constantly, particularly smartphone use and driving, so many are harboring irrational fears about it, instead of seeing any positives driving can offer them. She suggests parents make concerted efforts to make driving more interesting and non-threatening, and states,

You don’t want to force a child who isn’t ready, but at the same time you can show teens the dangers and be a good role model for them about the freedoms and fun driving affords us.

Adams also suggests using a third party driving instructor, either a professional, relative or family friend, because nervous teens often do better taking guidance and instruction from someone they see as less threatening than a parent.

There is no right or wrong answer to when and how a teen should start driving, because each enters the driving years with a different set of capabilities and characteristics that may make one eager to get their license on their birthday, and another with absolutely zero interest in driving at all.  But whenever and however parents decide to get their teens on the road should remain the family’s choice, and the one that is right for them.

You Might Also Enjoy Reading:

50 Things You Can Do When You Turn 18

9 Backpacks for College Kids and Teens

About Melissa Fenton

Melissa Fenton is a freelance writer and adjunct librarian at Pasco-Hernando State College. Find her writing all over the internet, but her work mostly on the dinner table. Find her on Facebook 
and on twitter at @melissarunsaway

Don't miss out!
Want more like this? Get updates straight to your inbox.