When my daughter turned 16, she announced she wanted a tattoo.
Caught off guard, I immediately said, “No!” She countered with, “Well, I have a friend who tattoos in his basement. I could just go there, and you’d never know.”

I felt that my daughter was too young for a tattoo
I didn’t fundamentally have a problem with tattoos, but she was only 16. I felt she was too young to make such a permanent decision. Teens often believe they know themselves completely and telling them otherwise doesn’t always go well. Tattoos are both permanent and painful, and I wasn’t sure she was ready to make a choice she might later regret.
She was determined, however, and the thought of her going to a high school classmate’s basement for permanent ink was alarming. We went back and forth, both holding our ground. We were at a standstill.
In some ways parenting my daughter was similar to training my horse
The situation reminded me of when I was retraining my horse Ace shortly after adopting him. He had been bred to race but did not do well on the track and was discarded. I adopted him from a rescue organization and planned to use him as a pleasure riding horse.
While working with Ace in the round pen, he would occasionally get stuck, literally. He would plant his feet and refuse to move. One of the exercises my trainer had me working on was to ask Ace to back up.

In some ways parenting my daughter was similar to training my horse
With this training exercise, I learned that I should not back up, only Ace should back up. In their own herds, the lead horse is the one that directs the movement and the retreat, so if I backed up, I would inadvertently confirm to Ace that he was the leader. However, if neither of us moved, we were simply stuck, our communication cut off entirely.
After standing and staring at each other for a while, I realized I could move sideways, rather than backward, to get him to shift. The sideways movement wasn’t perceived as a retreat, but as a way to change the course of our interaction without engaging in a battle of wills.
This lesson: redirect rather than retreat, became invaluable not only in training but in parenting, and in leadership in general. Faced with my daughter’s tattoo request, I realized I had to figure out how to get us unstuck. If I simply said yes, would she see it as a retreat? Would I set a precedent that she (and her siblings) could always wear me down? Maybe. But if I stayed firm in my “no,” it could lead to constant resistance, and I risked pushing her into a risky decision.
I had two choices when my daughter asked for a tattoo
Ultimately, she was leaving the door open for discussion, and it was up to me whether I left it open or slammed it shut. I saw two choices: Choice #1: Stick to my “no” and shut down any conversation about tattoos. The possible outcomes? She might obey me but harbor resentment, or she might go ahead and get the tattoo behind my back.
Then what could I do? Punish her? Take away her phone? Ground her? Would this lead to more secrecy, sneaking out, and a relationship built on dishonesty and resentment? I knew that wasn’t the kind of relationship I wanted with my daughter. I loved my mother, but we weren’t close when I was growing up. She wasn’t someone I confided in or sought advice from. This path didn’t feel right.
Choice #2: Reconsider, redirect, and negotiate. Could we discuss my concerns regarding hygiene, permanence, changing tastes, and find a compromise? At 16, teenagers crave autonomy.
As her mom, I needed to guide this moment
Silencing their voices doesn’t foster a strong future relationship. I realized, just like with Ace, that I needed to make the first move. I was the parent. I was the adult. I needed to guide this moment constructively keeping in mind that the relationship was more important than the conflict.
So, we negotiated. I agreed she could get a tattoo; she would pick the design and placement with my approval (no skull and cross bones). In return, I would select the tattoo studio and cover the cost. Tattoos are expensive, so this seemed like a fair compromise. Plus, I got to be there with her.
In many ways, tattooing today feels like the new ear piercing, and a mother-daughter rite of passage. I was thankful to be included in the experience. Did this mean we never had another conflict? Of course not. But it was a pivotal moment of growth. And the only precedent it set was that I would strive to redirect, negotiate, and keep communication open with all my children as they grew.
More Great Reading:









