Why Stress and Anxiety in Teens Can be Healthy: A Psychologist Explains

Psychologists have spent decades researching and treating both stress and anxiety. In fact, we understand these two phenomena as well as we understand anything in our field. But we haven’t always reached beyond our classrooms and clinical practices to share the science behind stress and anxiety. It’s time to get the word out, because what we know is surprisingly reassuring!

Top three things to know about stress and anxiety in teens

Anxiety Protects Us

To psychologists, anxiety is an evolutionary gift that keeps teenagers safe by alerting them to threats. For example, having a burst of anxiety when a nearby driver swerves into a teen’s lane will immediately sharpen his focus and inspire him to maneuver towards safety. Similarly, when a teenager puts off important tasks she’ll start to feel anxious, because by procrastinating too long she risks causing trouble for herself. Paying attention to anxiety helps teens stay on track.

Under Pressure

Teenagers sometimes worry that anxiety is unhealthy because it comes with uncomfortable physical symptoms such as a galloping heart and quickened breathing. But the physical symptoms of anxiety serve two important functions. First, the ringing of the bodily alarm system helpfully snaps teens to attention. Second, hearts race and breathing changes when teens feel anxious because anxiety activates the primitive fight-or-flight system that sends highly oxygenated blood to the muscles to help teenagers attack or run away from danger. The fight-or-flight system doesn’t always make sense in the face of ordinary, modern day threats, such as when a teen’s heart quickens simply because he has suddenly remembered a forgotten appointment. But it’s helpful for teenagers to appreciate the ancient logic behind the physical changes they experience when anxiety hits.

Stress Builds Capacity

Stress is an unavoidable part of life – and one that arises under positive and negative conditions. Getting married, moving into your dream house, or enjoying an outstanding personal achievement are all happy life experiences that nonetheless bring stress. Even welcome events cause stress when they involve adapting to new conditions. In fact, humans experience all change as stressful, because adaptation requires us to work at the edge of our current capacities.

We wouldn’t want teens to avoid stress, even if they could, because teens build their capacities when they stretch beyond their comfort zones. Going away to camp for a second summer is almost always easier than heading to camp the first summer, thanks to the growth that comes with being away from home the first time around. Even with unpleasant events such as being dumped or having a good friend move away, there are upsides to the stress. Research tells us that people who are able to weather challenging life experiences go on to be more resilient when faced with new difficulties.

Avoidance Feeds Anxiety

Humans instinctively avoid whatever we fear. Avoidance serves a useful purpose when it protects us from real dangers, such as poisonous snakes or dark alleyways. But avoiding aspects of everyday life, such as dogs or elevators, makes anxiety worse and can lead to full-blown phobias.

Avoidance doesn’t just feed anxiety, it serves up a two-course meal. First, avoidance brings immediate relief, which makes teens want to repeat the anxiety-avoidance-relief cycle. For example, a teenager who fears taking an elevator will feel much better if she decides to take the stairs instead. The next time she considers riding an elevator, she’ll remember how much better it felt to take the stairs and will want to repeat that experience.

Second, avoidance keeps teens from discovering that their fears are overblown; a teen who routinely takes the stairs never learns that elevators almost always work as they should. Instead of giving in to avoidance, it’s far better to help teens face their fears, even if they need to do so slowly and incrementally.

Though psychologists see anxiety and stress and normal, we also recognize that they can cross the line into unhealthy territory. Anxiety is unhealthy if it occurs in the absence of a threat or if the anxiety is much more intense than makes sense. For example, teens shouldn’t feel anxious when nothing is amiss, and a well-prepared student shouldn’t have a panic attack when taking a minor quiz. Stress is unhealthy if it is chronic—coming without breaks or any chance for recovery—or if it stems from emotionally overwhelming trauma. But even when anxiety and stress do reach unhealthy levels, psychologists can offer a variety of highly effective treatments.

The bottom line? It’s that there’s no need for teenagers (or anyone else, for that matter!) to feel anxious about feeling anxious or stressed about being stressed. Psychologists have long understood that both of these emotions are in most cases normal, helpful, and healthy aspects of being human.

You Might Also be Interested in Reading:

Lisa Damour Guides Parents Through Teen Turbulence in Untangled

How to Find a Therapist for Your College Student

About Lisa Damour

Dr. Lisa Damour is a psychologist and author of New York Times best-selling books Untangled: Guiding Teenage Girls Through the Seven Transitions into Adulthood and Under Pressure: Confronting the Epidemic of Stress and Anxiety in Girls

Dr. Damour is in private practice in Shaker Heights, Ohio, is a senior advisor to the Schubert Center for Child Studies at Case Western Reserve University and the executive director of Laurel School’s Center for Research on Girls. She is a regular contributor to CBS News and writes the monthly Adolescence column for the New York Times.  Connect with her on Facebook and Twitter

Read more posts by Lisa

Don't miss out!
Want more like this? Get updates straight to your inbox.