Is it Worth the Money?

Lisa and our good friend, Sharon Greenthal, who blogs at Empty House, Full Mind, asked the question “What is worth spending money on?” Money is a private and often touchy subject, yet the respondents were candid and their answers, revealing.  Here is the post appearing today on both blogs.

In the weeks between tossing out the turkey carcass and dragging the Christmas tree to the curb, the average American family is expected to spend $740 on gifts in this brief, intense shopping period. As the year winds down we will also give generously, writing checks for $79 billion in charitable donations or a quarter of our annual giving.

bank vault, money, bank

How we spend our money speaks to who we are and what we value. For each of us it is a trial and error process. We spend impulsively, and we live to regret the purchase. We save up carefully, and the object of our desire become obsolete or out of fashion. We buy things or experiences, we invest in education, and charity and with each step learn more about our personal relationships to money and more about ourselves.

How we spend our money is a sticky, complicated question that is burdened by the behavior of our family of origin and says something about the example we hope to set for our own children.

Recently we crowdsourced a big pool of midlifers. We hoped to find some wisdom about what is worth that extra spending. When do we spend money and feel great about it days, weeks and months later? What gives us lasting joy or just the thrill of the moment, and don’t we want a little of each?

Recent research seems to be conclusive on two matters.

First, when we spend money on others, it makes us happier than when we spend it on ourselves, Michael Norton of the Harvard Business School explains in his wildly popular TED talk. The tax year may be the cause of all that end of year giving, but there is real happiness to be found here.

Second, experiences make us happier than things. Our younger selves may not have understood this simple maxim, but when you query a group of people in midlife, it is clear that this is wisdom gained. There may be some things money can’t buy, but our readers tell us that there are a few things that it can:

  • Travel, travel, travel. Getting on a plane, boat or in a car ranked right up there at the top of our readers lists of the best way to spend money. And the only thing better than traveling, was traveling with family. Travel creates lifelong shared memories and made it to the top of most of our lists. Upgraded travel with better hotels or better seats on a plane were worth it, if the cost was manageable.
  • Education rated very high among our readers. University education for our kids was widely thought to be money very well spent. Some mentioned continuing education as well. Along those lines, tutoring and SAT prep classes are also considered a necessary expense.
  • We are happy to spend money to save time or increase comfort. Many readers mentioned spending money on housekeeping as a necessary luxury. Pedicures and massages made a great many lists as little comforts that go a long way.
  • A few of our friends fessed up: hair color. It may be temporary, but we walk out of that salon feeling a whole lot better.
  • Along the theme of experiences were tickets to shows, concerts, operas, movies or live music in a bar or on stage.
  • Good shoes also rated high. Not Manolos or Louboutins, but a really good quality, beautiful and above all comfortable shoe was right up there.
  • Technology is one of the “things” that makes us happy. Our computers and phones help us work better and faster, but far more than that they connect us to the people we love.
  • A nice meal at a restaurant with family or friends made many lists. Some considered it worth economizing in other areas in order to be able to afford this nicetie.
  • Professional or high quality photos of kids, not that kind that come out of our smartphones. We never get a chance to roll back the tape so a couple of times it is worth paying for the perfect family portrait.
  • Giving was high on many, many lists and it would be near the very top of ours, as well. Our readers know intuitively what Norton’s research bears out – making others happy, safe or secure makes us happy as well.

Finally a few of our readers mentioned chocolate. A fine bar of excellent dark chocolate, many believe is worth the extravagance, and who can argue with that.

Comments

  1. So true. Top of my list for birthday/Christmas (11 days apart) was “Experiences not things”. My husband prefers to take the easy way out and buy stuff I don’t want when he could get me tickets to ANYTHING and I would be thrilled.

  2. Oh how I wish we had the time and money to travel. I realized with alarm the other day that my passport expired since the last time I got to use it (not coincidentally right before I got pregnant with my first child over a dozen years ago). I’m hoping to save up enough to take my kids on some interesting trips while they are still living under our roof.

  3. Sue says:

    Another GREAT article, ladies! Time spent with the ones you love—worth more than anything money can buy!

  4. Such interesting information. Although, I do firmly believe that the best thing – spending time with loved ones – is free and can’t be beat. But spending money on comfy shoes, travel and hair color is almost right up there :)

  5. Carpool Goddess says:

    Great list! Food, comfort, education, travel, good shoes, oh well, most everything on your list, rates high with me. So hard to pick and choose, and even better when these experiences are shared with loved ones.

Trackbacks

  1. […] Dunn and Michael Norton explained that more money does not really make us happier and that it is what we do with our money that has the greatest impact on our happiness. Whether you are considering charitable giving of $25, […]