Grown and Flown in Today’s Wall Street Journal: Cheating in School

Wall Street Journal, WSJLisa writes: Last Fall, in the wake of a number of high-profile cheating scandals, Grown and Flown examined cheating in school.  We were surprised by some of the facts we uncovered. Technology, academic pressure and changing attitudes have increased the incidence of cheating in school and made it even more important that parents discuss this issue with kids from an early age.  It was our good fortune that The Wall Street Journal found us and included us in an article this morning entitled “How Could a Sweet Third-Grader Just Cheat on That School Exam?”

cheating in school, Wall Street Journal, kids cheating,

In this wonderful piece, Sue Shellenbarger finds that cheating is tricky parental terrain “The line between right and wrong in the classroom is often hazy for young children, and shaping the moral compass of children whose brains are still developing can be one of the trickiest jobs a parent faces.”  Shellenbarger found that rates of cheating rose as kids moved into middle school and high school and thus the conversation needs to start when school begins, as early as kindergarten.

Shellenbarger concludes her article with some of our thoughts about recognizing the situations our kids find themselves in and giving them advice that has the ring of truth.  The Wall Street Journal article can be found here.

Last fall we argued that the conventional wisdom surrounding cheating which suggests that we need to tell our children that cheating is wrong, that cheaters will probably get caught and certainly never prosper, was incorrect.  In this as in all parenting activities it is important to retain credibility.

cheating at school, wall street journal cheating story, kids cheating in school

By telling our children that classmates who cheat will get caught and will not benefit by their deceit, we will simply be seen as naive and hopelessly out of touch with the 21st century classroom.  Our kids don’t think cheaters fail to prosper, they think we fail to understand.

So this leaves the moral high ground; it is a tough place to stake out, a tough place to stay but ultimately, as parents, we know it is the right place to be.

The phrase I used with my kids was, “Take the D.”  If it is a choice between cheating and getting a lower grade–take the D.  I tried to convince them that they would rather face my short-lived disappointment with a poor grade than my devastation, humiliation and sadness at my failures in parenting and their faulty moral compass. I let them know that far from going to bat for them, if they were found to be cheating, I would let them burn in the fires of both their school’s and our home’s disciplinary hell.

So the conversation about cheating needs to begin early and happen often and it must be just that, a conversation, because situations and ethical dilemmas that we never faced will confront our kids every day.  It will ultimately be one of the most important conversations we will have because it touches the heart of everything we hope to do as parents in raising good people and good citizens.

Our original piece, Cheating in School: Start the Discussion Early can be found here.

Graphics Credit: WSJ, 5/15/2013



Did you like this post? The +1 tells Google it's great content! We appreciate your support.


Comments

  1. “I tried to convince them that they would rather face my short-lived disappointment with a poor grade than my devastation, humiliation and sadness at my failures in parenting and their faulty moral compass. ” SO, SO TRUE! Nice piece.
    lisa weldon recently posted..At the art galleryMy Profile

  2. Way to go ladies!

  3. Lisa @ Grandma's Briefs says:

    An excellent piece, here and there. Congratulations!

  4. happy outlook says:

    Great commentary on this subject. Congrats on being interviewed by the Wall Street Journal!

  5. Carpool Goddess says:

    Great advice Lisa! I’m with you all the way!
    Carpool Goddess recently posted..Mother’s Day 2013: Pancakes on the ceiling and other storiesMy Profile

  6. I like “Take the D.” I think for many kids as long as they feel valued for decency and hard work instead of the external trappings of success they will make better choices.
    Korinthia recently posted..Fire and FlowersMy Profile

  7. Congratulations on the WSJ coverage.
    Bravo on staking out and maintaining the moral high ground. What they learn at 6, they will practice at 60.

  8. Emily says:

    As usual, such great advice…I like the thinking of “take the D.” And a huge congrats on the Wall St. Journal — you ladies have hit the big time!!! :)
    Emily recently posted..Unsolicited Dinners Delivered To My Home? I Must Be Dreaming…My Profile

  9. Not too long ago my daughter said to me “I don’t understand why people cheat, then they’re not even learning the material”…in other words, missing out on the learning process. Have to say I appreciated that sentiment very much!
    Michelle recently posted..Celebrating a Life with a Tribute AlbumMy Profile

    • She sounds wise beyond her years. How wonderful that she already understands what is important.

  10. congratulations on the WSJ. very excited for you! i think my kids escaped the cheating pressure. when i see what the level of competition in children in elementary school, i wonder where our responsibility as adults lies in this. parents and educators have always wanted children to succeed and cheating has always been an issue, but it seems much bigger now but kids seem to be under a lot more pressure to succeed as well.
    sandy recently posted..MOTHERS DAY IN THE EMPTY NESTMy Profile

  11. Thumbs up! As a Third grade teacher I know by experience that students have it rough because for the first time, they have to deal with grades. School becomes real for both them and their parents. Parents begin turning on the pressure without being aware of how their children can react to it. Many of my students wouldn’t have the notion that sharing what they knew was wrong, so I would make it clear for them before tests would begin. You just can’t expect them to know things like this! Again, congrats on your post.

    Blessings,
    Maritza Martinez recently posted..How I Became A Gluten-Free MomMy Profile

  12. Magnificent site. Numerous helpful information and facts listed here. I am submitting them to 3 close friends ans furthermore expressing around scrumptious. And certainly, thank you for your energy!